Musical QA - guide-track-v2.json

Musical QA - guide-track-v2.json

• Verdict: simplify
• Guide type: vocal_phrasing
• Event count: 115
• Active tracks: muted_pulse, room_hum, vocal_marker
• Declared duration: 133.71s
• MIDI duration: 144.31s
• Audio duration: 138.00s

Issue Summary

• one_clear_lead_object: 1

Issues

• [one_clear_lead_object] Intro - 2 bars ambient pad only has no vocal lead object.

Warnings And Info

• [timing_grid] All events land within sixteenth-note grid tolerance.
• [guide_type_event_density] vocal_phrasing guide density is 25.8 events/30s.
• [duration_alignment] MIDI duration (144.31s) differs from declared duration (133.71s) by more than 0.5s.

Section Density

• Intro - 2 bars ambient pad only: 1 events over 8.0 beats
• Verse 1 - the thread was already there: 20 events over 24.0 beats
• Chorus 1 - where you been is good and gone (Apex D4): 14 events over 16.0 beats
• Verse 2 - the first pass was a word: 21 events over 24.0 beats
• Chorus 2 - Apex D4, slightly louder: 14 events over 16.0 beats
• Bridge - bird in the corner / caesura on immortal: 9 events over 16.0 beats
• Verse 3 - the passes went on (pull-back): 17 events over 24.0 beats
• Final Chorus - loudest section, full pulse, Apex D4: 14 events over 16.0 beats
• Outro - a cappella immortal: 5 events over 12.0 beats

Scores

• timing/groove lock: 3
• bass/percussion relationship: 1
• harmonic clarity: 1
• melody/motif clarity: 0
• lyric support: 2
• arrangement density: 3
• emotional fit: 1
• render clarity: 2
• platform usefulness: 0
• what should be simplified: 2